Skip to article
Websites & Conversion

Why Your Trade Website Is Not Getting Enquiries

A practical diagnostic for trade owners whose website has never produced a single enquiry, and an honest answer on whether it needs fixing or replacing.

30 July 202612 min readBy James Tandy
A builder's website open on a laptop beside a phone showing no new enquiries.

The short answer

A trade website that produces no enquiries is either invisible or unconvincing, and fifteen minutes in Google Search Console will tell you which. Under roughly a hundred visits a month is a traffic problem. Three hundred or more with a silent phone is a conversion problem.

Key takeaways

  • There are only two causes of a silent phone: nobody arrives, or everybody leaves. The fixes have nothing in common.
  • Fewer than about a hundred visits a month is a traffic problem, and no amount of redesign will fix it.
  • For most trades the Google Business Profile matters more than the website, and it is free to sort out first.
  • A homeowner gives you ten to twenty seconds to prove you do the job, cover their area, and can be trusted in their house.
  • Most trade sites need a day of fixes rather than a rebuild. Dated does not lose you work; slow and unclear do.

You paid for a website and it has never won you a job. That is a common story in the trades, and it is almost always fixable without starting again. The first job is working out whether your problem is traffic or conversion, because the two need completely different answers.

01

Two reasons a website is not getting enquiries: nobody arrives, or everybody leaves

Fifteen minutes of free checks separates a traffic problem from a conversion problem, and the two need completely different money.

There are only two reasons a website produces nothing. Either nobody is arriving, or people are arriving and leaving without contacting you. From where you are sitting the two look identical, because the symptom is the same silent phone. The fixes are nothing alike, and spending money on the wrong one is how most trade owners end up paying twice.

You can separate them in about fifteen minutes using free tools. Run these five checks before you spend anything.

  1. Verify your site in Google Search Console

    If it is not in there, do that first. It is the only place that tells you honestly how many times you appeared in Google and how many people clicked through.

  2. Read the last three months of clicks

    Set the date range to the last three months. The number you care about is total clicks, not impressions.

  3. Find your visitor numbers

    Check Google Analytics, or whatever your web designer installed. If nothing is installed at all, that is a finding in itself: the site was sold to you as a brochure, not as a tool for winning work.

  4. Search for yourself in an incognito window

    Search your main service and your town, on your phone rather than your laptop. Note where you actually appear: the map pack, the first page, page three, or nowhere at all.

  5. Compare your visits against the thresholds below

    Your monthly visitor number tells you which of the two problems you have, and therefore where the next pound should go.

How to read your monthly visitor number against the silent phone

Visits a month: Fewer than roughly 100

The problem you have
Traffic. Nobody is arriving.
Where to spend first
Local visibility. No amount of redesign will help, because there is nobody there to convert.

Visits a month: Somewhere in between

The problem you have
Probably a bit of both.
Where to spend first
Traffic first. A beautifully converting page with no visitors still earns nothing.

Visits a month: 300 or more

The problem you have
Conversion. People arrive and leave.
Where to spend first
The page itself. Buying more traffic will simply mean more people bouncing off the same page.

That last check, the incognito search on your own phone, tells you more than most agency reports do.

02

Why is my website not getting leads? Three reasons Google is not showing it

Almost no clicks means a visibility problem, and in my experience it comes down to site structure, the Business Profile, or missing service pages.

If Search Console shows almost no clicks, your website is not getting leads because Google is not showing it to anybody. Being online is not the same as being findable, and this is the part most trade owners are never told when they hand over their money.

Three causes account for nearly all of it.

The site was never built to rank

A five page site with a home page, an about page, a gallery, a services page and a contact page gives Google almost nothing to work with. It does not say what you do, in enough detail, in the places you do it.

Meanwhile the roofer three towns over has a page for flat roofing, a page for chimney repairs, a page for emergency leak repairs, and a page for each area he covers. He is not better at his trade than you. He just gave Google more to hold onto.

Your Google Business Profile is neglected

For most trades the profile matters more than the website does. The map pack sits above the ordinary results on a phone screen. If your profile is unverified, has the wrong categories, has no photos, or has no reviews, you are invisible in the exact place where people with an urgent job look first.

Map pack
The block of local businesses shown with a map above the ordinary blue links. On a phone it often fills the first screen, which is why it matters more than a website for urgent work.

There are no individual service pages

If somebody types boiler replacement plus their town, Google wants to show a page about boiler replacement in that town. A single page listing fourteen services in bullet points is not that page. It ranks for nothing in particular because it is about nothing in particular.

None of this is quick. Local visibility builds over weeks and months, not days, and anybody who promises you a position by a certain date is guessing. But it is entirely learnable, and the free audit will tell you which of these three is holding you back.

03

Website not converting: the three questions a homeowner answers in ten seconds

With decent traffic and no calls, the page is failing a quick test on a phone: what you do, where you work, and whether you can be trusted.

The harder case is a website not converting despite decent traffic. Hundreds of people are landing on your site every month, and not one of them picks up the phone. That is not bad luck. That is your page failing a test it never told you it was taking.

Somebody has a leak, or a dead consumer unit, or a kitchen they want ripping out. They search, they open three or four results in tabs, and they spend maybe ten to twenty seconds on each one deciding whether it is worth reading properly. They are not admiring your website. They are trying to answer three questions very quickly.

  • Does this person do the thing I need?
  • Do they cover where I live?
  • Can I trust them with my house and my money?

If your page does not answer all three above the fold, they close the tab and ring the next result. They will not scroll to find out. They have two other tabs open and one of them is easier to read than yours.

A good looking site can still convert nothing

Design and conversion are related but they are not the same thing. I have seen smart, expensive looking sites that never say which towns they cover, and plain sites with a phone number the size of a fist that keep a two van operation booked out.

The other half of it is trust

A homeowner is deciding whether to let a stranger into their house. Stock photography of somebody else's van, no real photographs of your own work, no company number, no address, and a generic contact form all read as risk. You know you are legitimate. The page has to prove it in seconds to somebody who has never heard of you.

04

The seven things that stop trade websites converting

Speed, proof, clarity, coverage, contact details, form length and differentiation: in my experience these seven account for most lost enquiries, and they rarely turn up alone.

In my experience the same seven problems account for most of it, and they rarely turn up alone. Find your own symptom below rather than reading the lot.

1. Slow loading on a phone

Most of your visitors are on a phone, often on mobile data, sometimes standing in a wet loft. If your home page carries a huge slideshow, four tracking scripts and photographs straight off a camera at full size, it will take several seconds to appear, and a good share of people leave before they see anything at all. Test your own site on 4G rather than on the office wifi.

2. No proof of work

Trades sell on evidence. Ten clear photographs of jobs you have actually finished, with a line about what the problem was and what you did, beat any amount of copy about being reliable and professional.

3. Services a homeowner cannot identify

If a homeowner cannot tell within a few seconds whether you do the specific thing they need, they assume you do not. Name the jobs plainly, in the words customers use, not in trade shorthand.

4. No service areas named

If your site never names the towns and postcodes you cover, every visitor has to guess, and a fair number will guess wrong and leave. Say where you work, in writing, on the page.

5. Contact details buried

A phone number sitting only in the footer, or hidden behind a menu on mobile, costs you calls every week. It belongs at the top of every page, as tappable text, not inside an image.

6. A form that asks too much

Nobody filling in a form at half past nine at night wants to supply a full address, a budget bracket and a preferred start date. Name, phone, and one line about the job is enough. You can ask everything else when you ring them back.

7. No reason to choose you over the next result

Most trade sites are interchangeable. If your page could have somebody else's logo dropped onto it and still make sense, you have not given anybody a reason to stop searching.

05

The afternoon checklist: audit your own site on your own phone

Six checks you can run cold from a search result, most of which turn out to be an hour of editing rather than a rebuild.

Set aside an afternoon and go through your own site on your phone, as if you were a homeowner who has never heard of you. Do not use your laptop and do not use the version you have in your head. Open it cold, from a search result, and be hard on it.

  1. Look at the first screen only

    Without scrolling, can you see what trade this is, which towns it covers, and how to get in touch? If any of the three is missing, that is your first job of the afternoon, and it is usually an hour of editing rather than a rebuild.

  2. Tap your phone number

    Does it dial? On a surprising number of trade sites the number is part of an image, or it is plain text that does nothing when tapped.

  3. Fill in your own form with one thumb

    Do it honestly, on your phone, and count the fields. If there are more than four, cut it back.

  4. Check the enquiry actually arrives

    Send the form and confirm it lands in an inbox somebody reads, not in a spam folder or an old address belonging to whoever built the site.

  5. Open your services

    Does each main service have its own page, with a few hundred words about what the job involves, what it typically costs and what happens next? Or is everything crammed onto one page as a list?

  6. Look hard at your photographs

    Are they your jobs, or are they stock images? A homeowner can tell the difference, and so can I.

Finally, read your home page out loud and ask what it promises that the next result does not. If the answer is nothing, write the honest thing instead: how quickly you answer the phone, how long you have been trading, what you refuse to take on. Specific and unglamorous beats vague and polished every time.

06

When a rebuild is justified, and when it is an expensive way to edit

Most trade sites need a day of fixes rather than a new build, and there are only five conditions where I would tell you to start again.

I will say the unflattering thing, given I sell websites: most trade sites do not need rebuilding. They need a handful of fixes that a competent person can make in a day.

If your site loads reasonably quickly, you can edit it yourself, and it simply lacks service pages, service areas, real photographs and a visible phone number, then rebuilding is an expensive way to solve an editing problem. Fix what is there and spend the difference on your Google Business Profile and your local visibility instead.

A rebuild is justified in fewer cases than most agencies would like you to believe. These are the five.

  • The site is not mobile friendly at all and has to be pinched and zoomed.
  • It is built on a platform you cannot get into, or the person who made it has vanished and nobody has the login.
  • It takes eight seconds to load and every page is one enormous image.
  • It sits on an abandoned system that no longer receives security updates.
  • The structure is so flat that there is genuinely nowhere to put service and area pages.

Dated does not lose you work. Slow, unclear and untrustworthy lose you work, and all three can exist behind a very fashionable design.

If it does turn out you need to start again, my own websites are a fixed £1,995, and the web design for tradesmen page sets out exactly what that includes and what it does not. If it turns out you do not need one, I would rather tell you that than sell you one.

07

What to do next, in order

Diagnose first, then fix the one problem you actually have, and give local search a few months before judging it.

Work through it in order, and give it a few months before you judge the result. Local search does not respond overnight and anybody telling you otherwise is selling something.

  1. Check Search Console and your visitor numbers, so you know whether you are dealing with traffic or conversion.
  2. If it is traffic, claim and fill out your Google Business Profile properly, then start building service and area pages.
  3. If it is conversion, spend an afternoon on the checklist above: phone number at the top, service areas named, real photographs, a short form you have tested yourself.

If you would rather have somebody else look at it, send it to me. The free audit is reviewed personally by me, not run through a tool, and you get it back within three working days. There is no sales call attached to it, and if the honest answer is that your site is fine and your problem is your Google Business Profile, that is what the audit will say. If a rebuild genuinely is the right answer, the web design for tradesmen page explains what that looks like.

The bottom line

A website not getting enquiries is either invisible or unconvincing, and you can tell which in fifteen minutes. Most sites need a day of fixes rather than a rebuild, so diagnose before you spend. If you want a second opinion, Get My Free Website Audit: reviewed personally, back within three working days, no sales call.

Where to go next

Sources

James Tandy, founder of JTandy

Written by James Tandy

James builds high-converting websites and runs local SEO for UK home-service businesses, with ten years spent turning local search into booked jobs. More about James →

Start with the audit

Find out where your website is losing trust and enquiries.

Request a free website audit. I’ll personally review the important opportunities and tell you honestly whether a rebuild is justified.

  • Free
  • Reviewed personally
  • No sales call
  • Yours to keep
Get My Free Website Audit →